“Mass advertising can help build brands,” longtime Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz as soon as prophesized, “but authenticity is what makes them last.” As company cheerleading goes, that is a permanent fable. Authenticity has change into a central ethical framework in society–the refined but pervasive worth that animates and adjudicates our media, tradition, and politics. Merriam-Webster recently introduced that “authentic” was its 2023 phrase of the yr, because of a surge in on-line search queries.
Shoppers have lengthy sought authenticity, because it will get stamped on a variety of products and experiences made engaging largely as a result of they seem to lack market motives. The mom-and-pop diner; the vinyl document store–the native and uncommercialized. Assume dive bars, farmers markets, and indie cinemas.
Research discover that customers rate unbiased, family-run outposts extra genuine than chains–and even shrug off hygiene code violations if a hole-in-the-wall appears sufficiently off the crushed path. Authenticity additionally beckons vacationers, pointing towards paths less traveled resembling Cuba, Bhutan, or Burning Man.
A quest for the distinctive
Scholarly articles about authenticity greater than doubled within the 2010s and main pollster John Zogby found that it topped the record of Individuals’ cultural yearnings.
“You have aspirational positioning from every brand out there to want to make their offering feel bespoke and handcrafted and unique,” one advertising COO quips. “The fact of the matter is that there’s tens of thousands of others of that [product] pumping out every single week.”
That quest for authenticity is, briefly, a quest for uniqueness amidst homogenous mass manufacturing. As we speak’s customers search what one philosopher-critic known as “aura”–a singular product relative to the readily replicable. Social theorist Andreas Reckwitz diagnoses customers as in thrall to “singularities”–distinctive objects, areas, and experiences that fulfill cultural wishes somewhat than useful wants that meeting strains as soon as merely glad.
Franchising, particularly, embodies McWorld alienation as companies implement formulaic operations that erode native character: nondescript workplace parks, suburban tract properties, and informal eating chains. Most can’t protect nuance on the large scale that revenue calls for.
The extra sameness is obtainable, the extra customers go looking for one thing actual to seize onto and uncover themselves inside. Name this the id politics of the buying cart.
A manufactured very best
As a concept, authenticity hatched in response to 18th– and 19th-century industrialization. Humanity’s relationship with machines turned disenchanted, not simply at work–the place effectivity, automation, and amount dominated values–but additionally with this logic spilling into client experiences.
Though authenticity cannot be present in Victorian-era vocabulary about merchandise, by 1908 Coca-Cola was already pitching itself as “genuine”–a part of producers’ efforts to influence that their model was extra pure and conventional than fellow factory-line merchandise filling dwelling cabinets. This rhetoric intensified lately.
Take Starbucks, which has lengthy tried to breed the “aura” of that cute, little indie espresso store in your neighborhood–some 55,000 times over. Its model guidebook reportedly mandates 5 beliefs that needed to apply to each design alternative: handcrafted; inventive; subtle; human; and enduring. These search to persuade you that this Starbucks is actually distinctive and particular, not like the (identical) one a block away.
Therefore, the interiors’ aesthetic accentuation–earth hues, wicker baskets, curvy motifs, stained woods, unfinished metals–all to distinction the prepackaged synthetics that envelop quick meals. Therefore, too, the client’s identify learn aloud somewhat than an automatic receipt quantity–simulating rituals of familiarity and custom.
Starbucks doesn’t change into globally ubiquitous if it may possibly’t faux authenticity on this vogue, even when being globally ubiquitous inherently invalidates that.
The authenticity very best is artisanal craft, romantically conjuring premodern labor untainted by large equipment. Items which are “handmade” in “small-batch” versus cash-grab; cabinets which are curated, not commercialized.
Origin tales additionally authenticate, looking for to make an organization genealogically reliable by emphasizing a degree or individual of provenance. Assume Ben & Jerry’s right here, or the naïve moral authenticity of any beginner startup tinkering in a storage for love somewhat than cash.
Research means that an organization’s founding intent issues an excellent deal to customers: If seen as “self-transcendent” (i.e., for society or neighborhood) somewhat than for “self-enhancement” (wealth or standing), the model scans genuine. Greed, for lack of a greater phrase, isn’t good at conveying that.
Authenticity additionally explains a latest swing towards classic aesthetics–campaigns, slogans, and logos from yesteryear dusted off and trotted out, from Pizza Hut’s pink roof icon to Miller Lite’s throwback font: “Brands want to say, ‘We’re still that same company with humble roots,’” one model strategist explained. “So [they] reverse-engineer that value to an audience that may not be privy to a backstory.”
This, then, is the last word contrivance: For a century, companies have tried to promote us they’ve a “soul.” As one promoting artistic director rhapsodizes, “Brands have to have a voice; they have to have character; they have to have morals.”
To that finish, Dunkin’ Donuts shortened the identify on its (11,000-plus) shops to simply “Dunkin’” to “highlight how the brand was now on a first-name basis with fans,” even gifting away “handmade friendship bracelets” to commemorate the copyright registry.
To make certain, there’s something comprehensible, but lamentable, in that notion. You’ll be able to’t be mates with an LLC, but anthropomorphism stays the central delusion of branding. Authenticity is, in any case, a nostalgic reflex. We yearn for it most in occasions of fast change. A lot as industrialization generated a eager for agrarian simplicity a century in the past, at this time’s high-tech panorama–one in all AI chatbots and digital deepfakes–generates a lot the identical wistfulness for a world being misplaced.
Michael Serazio is an affiliate professor of communication at Boston School and the creator of, most lately, The Authenticity Industries: Protecting it ‘Real’ in Media, Tradition & Politics.
Extra must-read commentary printed by Fortune:
- Financial pessimists’ guess on a 2023 recession failed. Why are they doubling down in 2024?
- COVID-19 v. Flu: A ‘much more serious threat,’ new research into long-term dangers concludes
- Entry to fashionable stoves may very well be a game-changer for Africa’s financial growth–and assist lower the equal of the carbon dioxide emitted by the world’s planes and ships
- The U.S.-led digital commerce world order is under attack–by the U.S.
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary items are solely the views of their authors and don’t essentially replicate the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
