Union Pacific Company: New Administration Key To Superior Returns (NYSE:UNP)

Funding Thesis

Union Pacific Company (NYSE:UNP) is rated as a purchase as operations enhance. We consider the brand new administration will proceed implementing vital enhancements that can allow UNP to unlock superior shareholder returns. Earlier administration delivered a poor multi-year operational efficiency and at its present valuation, UNP is a long-term purchase.

Introduction

UNP is likely one of the Class 1 freight railroad firms in the US. The corporate is 161 years previous and its rail community covers 23 states. UNP’s rail community is beneath indicating good protection throughout the U.S.

We strongly consider that UNP will embark on a multi-year interval of enhancements and development unlocking shareholder returns. The principle purpose for that is twofold. Firstly, UNP appointed Jim Vena as the brand new CEO of the corporate efficient August 2023. We predict the brand new CEO is the best particular person to rework UNP into an environment friendly railway firm unlocking shareholder returns. He has over 40 years of expertise within the {industry} and is aware of UNP as he served because the UNP COO and advisor to the chairman up to now. Secondly, U.S. railways stand to learn from a number of tailwinds. If administration achieves operational enhancements then the impression will probably be vital as they may be capable to capitalise on these tailwinds. Tailwinds for the U.S. railway firms embrace the elevated investments occurring for the U.S. industries and the truth that railways are a type of greener transport when put next with alternate options reminiscent of truck deliveries. The U.S. funding cycle is pushed by the onshoring of provide chains which can take vital investments to reverse the previous development of offshoring and the decarbonisation efforts from authorities and {industry}. A transparent instance of that is the recent infrastructure invoice signed by the U.S. authorities of c.$1.2 trillion. Loads of these new investments and initiatives will want help from railways for transportation. As well as, given that companies and society turn into extra delicate to the sustainability of products we count on railways to realize market share from vans for instance. Railways are thought-about a greener various and with the restricted extra investments wanted to capitalise on this, we count on that their market share will enhance through the years.

Therefore, the important thing to superior shareholder returns is administration’s capability to ship. We discuss concerning the early indicators beneath.

Administration and Operational Efficiency

Our opinion is that UNP’s previous administration has did not unlock most of UNP’s worth and in consequence shareholder returns have been beneath these of rivals.

That is indicated by the chart beneath which is the 5-year chart as much as 26 February 2023, the date when UNP introduced that they’re searching for a brand new CEO. As indicated beneath, UNP underperformed materially when put next with {industry} rivals.

As we talked about above the brand new CEO was put in place efficient 13 August 2023. Since then there have been just a few key modifications that we consider have been essential in establishing UNP to enhance and unlock shareholder worth.

To start out with, the corporate appointed completely different individuals within the place of CEO and chairman of the board. Earlier than Lance Fritz was filling each roles. The truth that a CEO is accountable to the board of administrators and in consequence, the chairman, implies that having completely different individuals filling the completely different roles creates some accountability. Having the identical particular person because the CEO and as a md implies that firms can hand over an excessive amount of affect on one particular person and take away accountability. Having these roles break up implies that the board of administrators can deal with setting the best aims and incentives for the CEO to make sure shareholder worth is unlocked. Moreover, if a CEO isn’t performing nicely sufficient then the board of administrators can extra simply fireplace the CEO if they aren’t appearing because the chairman of the board having vital affect.

Secondly, Jim Vena arrange a brand new multi-year technique tackling UNP’s issues. The strategy is “Safety + Service & Operational Excellence = Growth.” Within the 2023 annual report, Jim Vena summarises the aim of this technique succinctly.

Security is UNP’s first space of focus because it units the best mindset, tradition, and private accountability. Service is the main target to ship what guarantees have been made to clients and lastly, operational excellence is the flexibility to function effectively and productively. Attaining all three will result in UNP rising its enterprise and make UNP an {industry} chief unlocking superior shareholder returns.

Why is that this essential? As a result of the earlier administration failed to attain these targets resulting in inferior shareholder returns. Lance Fritz’s efficiency as a CEO was considered one of poor shareholder return, poor security, poor income development and poor price administration. UNP grew to become the go-to railway firm to focus on what to not do as a railway firm. For instance, in Q3 2023 UNP obtained a letter from regulators stating how unsafe the trains and the gear used have been.

On the income and price administration efficiency facet of issues, we will evaluate UNP’s efficiency with Canadian Pacific Kansas Metropolis Restricted (CP) which is a well-run railway firm in our opinion. As we will see beneath because the appointment of Lance Fritz, CP had superior income development and a greater EBIT margin.

The query then turns into how is Jim Vena doing? We predict there are already optimistic outcomes showing within the enterprise outcomes.

Firstly, let’s study the weekly 2023 efficiency metrics knowledge since Jim Vena took over relative to a 12 months in the past (we’re evaluating August to December 2023 with August to December 2022 common weekly knowledge).

Click on to enlarge

In all 4 of the metrics, Jim Vena has higher efficiency relative to the efficiency underneath the previous CEO. For freight automobile velocity and prepare velocity, larger figures are higher and for change and run-through automobile dwell and working automobile stock, decrease figures are higher.

If you’re questioning what these metrics are we offer some explanations beneath. Definitions can be discovered here.

Automotive Velocity: Measures the typical day by day miles a automobile strikes. Extra miles imply higher utilisation of freight vehicles.

Practice Velocity: Measures the time from origin departure till ultimate arrival, together with time at intermediate terminals. Extra miles per hour means higher utilisation of trains.

Swap & Run-through Automotive Dwell: Measures dwell in hours for any automobile classification or run-through prepare exercise at a railroad station. The upper the figures the longer the dwell time and the decrease the utilisation.

Working Automotive Stock: Each day snapshot of vehicles in regular motion, maintain, or launched at buyer standing. Signifies how nicely stock is managed. If the quantity goes down it implies that your stock is managed extra successfully.

These operational metric enhancements are additionally current within the 2024 year-to-date knowledge when put next with the equal interval one 12 months prior.

Operational enhancements are additionally current within the This fall 2023 results. Quarterly freight automobile velocity noticed a 14% year-on-year enchancment. Quarterly locomotive productiveness improved by 14% 12 months on 12 months. Common most prepare size noticed a 2% year-on-year enhance. Quarterly workforce productiveness improved by 4% to 1,051 automobile miles per worker and lastly, the gasoline consumption charge of 1.091, measured in gallons of gasoline per thousand GTMs, deteriorated by 3% in comparison with a 12 months in the past. All of those efficiency metrics are transferring in direction of the best route and their steady enchancment will result in superior shareholder returns.

What about shareholder returns? The chart beneath begins from the interval following the announcement of the previous administration stepping down. Since then UNP noticed a stronger efficiency than most of its rivals. As well as, the spike in UNP’s inventory worth across the twenty sixth of July is the impact of Jim Vena’s announcement as the brand new UNP CEO.

General throughout their first months, it’s clear that the brand new administration is taking the proper actions to enhance UNP’s operational efficiency. In our opinion, if administration continues to incrementally enhance UNP’s operational efficiency and achieves industry-leading metrics shareholders will profit from superior returns. Small incremental enhancements over an extended interval can have a big impression on the enterprise.

Relative Valuation

Beneath we take a look at UNP’s relative valuation in comparison with Canadian Nationwide Railway Firm (CNI), CSX Company (CSX), Norfolk Southern Company (NSC) and Canadian Pacific Kansas Metropolis Restricted (CP).

Click on to enlarge

As we will see above UNP sits in the midst of the valuation vary, with CSX being the comparatively cheaper choice and CP the costliest one primarily based on valuation multiples. On a relative valuation foundation, UNP appears to be pretty valued.

Secondly, allow us to take a look at absolutely the valuation multiples because the previous administration introduced they’d be stepping down.

As we will see from the charts above on an absolute foundation all valuation multiples have expanded since February 2023. Extra particularly, the price-to-earnings ratio rose by 24%, the price-to-free money circulation ratio elevated by 36% and the enterprise worth to earnings earlier than curiosity and tax elevated by 20%. Though these multiples have expanded over the past 12 months if UNP achieves industry-leading operational efficiency we consider that multiples will develop additional.

If administration can enhance its working ratio (working bills divided by income) nearer to the CP’s working ratio we count on valuation multiples to additional enhance nearer to CP’s ratios.

This goes again to the significance that administration will play in unlocking shareholder worth. Incremental enhancements over an extended interval will result in larger profitability, larger valuation multiples and better shareholder returns.

Dangers

As we mentioned above our thesis is concentrated on administration unlocking superior shareholder returns. New administration has demonstrated early on that they will enhance the corporate’s operations. The primary indicators are encouraging, nonetheless, there’s the chance that administration will fail to ship significant and extra enhancements. On condition that on a relative valuation foundation UNP appears to be in the midst of the vary, operational enhancements are key to unlock superior returns. These early optimistic operational efficiency indicators may be all the way down to poor luck. Operational efficiency must be monitored for longer to declare victory by administration. As well as, UNP’s enterprise is delicate to the financial cycles. If the economic system enters into a tough recession financial exercise will doubtless decline which can impression demand and therefore the enterprise as a complete. No administration enhancements will result in superior shareholder returns if the economic system enters right into a recession.

Conclusion

The brand new administration has offered early indicators that it may possibly enhance UNP’s operational efficiency. Bettering their efficiency over time will allow them to turn into an {industry} chief and capitalise on the tailwinds we mentioned above. On a relative foundation, UNP is on the center of the valuation a number of vary. Therefore, administration must proceed to operationally enhance the efficiency of the corporate. We consider over the long run administration will proceed to attain significant enhancements that can translate to superior shareholder returns. We charge UNP as a long-term purchase.