What’s Mistaken with TikTok’s Viral Budgeting Pattern

Budgeting might be tough and time-consuming. “Cash stuffing,” also called the envelope methodology, has emerged lately as a simple cash administration device that permits customers to place laborious limits on their spending.

It is discovered rising reputation on TikTok, the place clips with the hashtags “#cashstuffing”, “#cashenvelopesystem” and “#cashenvelopes” have garnered greater than 3 billion views mixed.

A giant a part of money stuffing’s attraction is its simplicity: Each month, adherents merely divvy up their funds amongst envelopes dedicated to totally different spending classes. However is that this low-tech approach budgeting technique?

Under, CNBC Select explores the professionals and cons of money stuffing, in addition to options that supply extra bang in your buck.

What we’ll cowl

What’s money stuffing?

Advantages of money stuffing

Dangers of money stuffing

There is not any two methods about it: Having massive quantities of money at house is dangerous. Should you have been robbed or there was a hearth, that cash can be gone eternally. (Even a disobedient dog might value you 1000’s.)

Say goodbye to on-line purchasing, too. Not only for garments and different merchandise, however film tickets and meals. And all these journeys to the ATM and money register are time-consuming.

Paying in money additionally means you will not benefit from the purchase protection and rewards programs most bank cards include. The American Express® Gold Card, for instance, affords 4X Membership Rewards® factors at eating places and grocery shops and 3X on flights booked immediately with airways or by

Members who hyperlink their card to the Uber app can even get a credit score of as much as $120 yearly to make use of on Uber rides and Uber Eats orders within the U.S.

American Express® Gold Card

On the American Categorical safe web site

  • Rewards

    4X Membership Rewards® factors at Eating places (plus takeout and supply within the U.S.) and at U.S. supermarkets (on as much as $25,000 per calendar 12 months in purchases, then 1X), 3X factors on flights booked immediately with airways or on, 1X factors on all different purchases

  • Welcome bonus

    Earn 60,000 Membership Rewards® factors after you spend $6,000 on eligible purchases together with your new Card throughout the first 6 months of Card Membership.

  • Annual payment

  • Intro APR

  • Common APR

  • Steadiness switch payment

  • International transaction payment

  • Credit score wanted

Most significantly, utilizing the envelope methodology signifies that cash will not be accruing any curiosity. The Milli Savings Account is a high-yield savings account with a 5.5% annual share yield. There is not any minimal opening deposit and no upkeep or overdraft charges.

There’s even a budgeting function that lets account holders distribute cash into as much as 5 totally different “jars” and calculate how a lot they should meet that monetary objective.

Milli Savings Account SMALL

  • Annual Proportion Yield (APY)

  • Minimal stability

    No minimal stability requirement

  • Month-to-month payment

  • Most transactions

  • Extreme transactions payment

  • Overdraft charges

  • Supply checking account?

  • Supply ATM card?

Counting on paper cash can also encourage irresponsible spending. A 2023 analysis of greater than 118,000 transactions discovered consumers tended to make use of money for purchases they felt responsible about or did not wish to take into consideration later, since bank cards depart extra of a path.

Alternate options to money stuffing

If you wish to work in your budgeting however do not wish to surrender the benefit and perks of bank cards, you’ve got some choices. CNBC Choose’s alternative for the best cash-back credit card, the Chase Freedom Unlimited® card comes with the Chase Spending Planner, which breaks down your spending into classes and allows you to monitor day by day and month-to-month spending.

The cardboard additionally affords 5% money again on journey bought by Chase Final Rewards®, 3% money again on drugstores and eating places and 1.5% money again on all different purchases.

Chase Freedom Unlimited®

  • Rewards

    Take pleasure in 4.5% money again on drugstore purchases and eating at eating places, together with takeout and eligible supply companies, 6.5% money again on journey bought by Chase Final Rewards®, our premier rewards program that permits you to redeem rewards for money again, journey, reward playing cards and extra; and three% money again on all different purchases (on as much as $20,000 spent within the first 12 months). After your first 12 months or $20,000 spent, take pleasure in 5% money again on Chase journey bought by Final Rewards®, 3% money again on drugstore purchases and eating at eating places, together with takeout and eligible supply service, and limitless 1.5% money again on all different purchases.

  • Welcome bonus

    INTRO OFFER: Earn a further 1.5% money again on every part you purchase (on as much as $20,000 spent within the first 12 months) – value as much as $300 money again!

  • Annual payment

  • Intro APR

    0% for the primary 15 months from account opening on purchases and stability transfers

  • Common APR

  • Steadiness switch payment

    Intro payment of both $5 or 3% of the quantity of every switch, whichever is bigger, on transfers made inside 60 days of account opening. After that, both $5 or 5% of the quantity of every switch, whichever is bigger.

  • International transaction payment

  • Credit score wanted

  • Member FDIC. Phrases apply.

Should you simply need a cash administration device, the You Need a Budget (YNAB) app is a digital model of the envelope methodology. Customers allot funds to a spending class, or “job,” till all of their obtainable cash is assigned. There is a 34-day free trial interval and you may hyperlink accounts and set spending targets.

You Need a Budget (YNAB)

  • Price

    34-day free trial then $99 per 12 months or $14.99 per thirty days (college students who present proof of enrollment get 12 months free)

  • Standout options

    As an alternative of utilizing conventional budgeting buckets, customers allocate each greenback they earn to one thing (often called the “zero-based budgeting system” the place no greenback is unaccounted for). Each greenback is assigned a “job,” whether or not it is to go towards payments, financial savings, investments, and so on.

  • Categorizes your bills

  • Hyperlinks to accounts

    Sure, financial institution and bank cards

  • Availability

    Provided in each the App Retailer (for iOS) and on Google Play (for Android)

  • Security measures

    Encrypted information, accredited information facilities, third-party audits and extra

Subscribe to the CNBC Choose Publication!

Cash issues — so profit from it. Get knowledgeable ideas, methods, information and every part else it’s essential to maximize your cash, proper to your inbox. Sign up here.

Backside line

Money stuffing may attraction to shoppers preferring simplicity or have issues with impulse management. However the danger of getting all that money round — to not point out lacking out on curiosity and card rewards — ought to make you assume twice earlier than labeling all these envelopes.

Why belief CNBC Choose?

Editorial Be aware: Opinions, analyses, evaluations or suggestions expressed on this article are these of the Choose editorial employees’s alone, and haven’t been reviewed, accredited or in any other case endorsed by any third occasion.